It's not about cheating...

[doddiemoemoe]

No: HPFGUIDX 165450

I truly believe JKR put in snape's "old"/"former" potion book to 
represent her upcoming book/books....and to let us know there are no 
true answers eithical, academic or otherwise.... the only one thing 
one may expound upon regarding Harry's potion book in HBP is why 
Hermione never asked to read it...(obvious for Hermione who wants 
the official version).....but ron could have read it as well...AND 
ron had more access to said book than anyone else besides harry, yet 
he chose not to read it..and, yet,  no one could doubt Ron's 
adolescent distractions....eels, eels and more eels....(I remember 
fishing for them and selling them to our local chinese restaurants 
sad, yet very true..)

Besides which,  it would be great if the Lilly connection was more 
than green eyes in the HBP...what if she made the annotations of 
better yet....snape made them...copying off of her...with lily 
giving chance after chance...to snape...until he called her 
a "mudblood"...and we saw her response.....

I dunno...

what if Harry's Neville......Is akin to Lilly's Snape...(woohoo for 
neville who needs no mysetery or shadows--yet he has them in 
plenty...yet apparently snape needs them...--which of course he 
would, he's a death eater...

Now, in the arena of snape.......if we are to compare Neville to 
Snape...to whom shall we choose...and if Lilly's snape betrayed 
her....shall it be Neville that betrays harry....did Dumbledore make 
a horrific promise long ago?

anywho,
this is where I'm at right now...I'm goint back to start again at 
book one...

DD