[HPforGrownups] Bill and Snape and Horcruxes

[ginger mabayoje]

No: HPFGUIDX 165504

justcarol67 wrote:
<snip>But Snape is probably the only person aside from Bill Weasley who can help Harry with Horcruxes and the only one who can help him locate them. 

sweetophelia4u says:
Hi, I'm new here. Perhaps this comment refers to a previous thread? If not, could you please explain your reasoning behind Bill and Snape being the only ones who can help Harry with the Horcruxes? Thanks.

Funkeginger
   I don't get what you mean that Bill is the only one who can help Harry.
 
   I get what you're saying about Snape, the guy's really skilled in all that dark stuff but Bill?  I know he's an ok Wizard but Harry's last hope, I don't know about that man.  Do you know something about the Deathly Hallows that the rest of us don't know?

   I don't think that anyone can help Harry out other then RAB whoever that is if they are alive.  A friend and I have this belief that Snape really is not bad even through he killed Dumbledore.  We think that when Dumbledore was saying "Please Severus" that he was begging for Snape to kill him.  Maybe so You Know Who does not find out about the Horcruxes.  I mean it's kind of funny Snape saw Dumbledore really weak and not even being able to stand.  Logically if you see one of the greatest Wizards of that time so weak and unable to stand, you have to ask yourself how they got that way.  Snape was always logical.  So I want to know why he did react to the way Dumbledore looked before he killed him. 

      Also how come Dumbledore trusted Snape so much if he did not have a good reason, and two Snape was a Death Eater.  Up until he died, Dumbledore had to see Snape right when he got back from the Cave. I don't think that Dumbledore could be that dumb.  How could he be wrong and Harry right all these years?  I think there was more behind it then and that JK Rowling is a really smart person.  I bet she wants everyone to think Snape is bad, but in the end he will help Harry or we will find out what Snape did for Dumbledore to make him trust him so much.