Snape, a Deatheater.

[dumbledore11214]

No: HPFGUIDX 163527

Re: Snape, a Deatheater. 


> Sherry now:
<SNIP>
I don't know if I think he supports
> Voldemort or was just being a coward and saving his own skin, in
true
> Slytherin style.
> After all, Phineas Nigelus said that a Slytherin would save his
own skin
> first.
<SNIP>


Alla:

Heee, you know that our feelings about Snape are pretty much
identical and I certainly think that Snape being a coward on the
Tower and saving himself from consequences of UV that he got himself
into is a strong possibility.

I am just thinking that I am not sure how much Phineas words truly
reflect Slytherin profile, so to speak.

I am saying it because of Regulus' actions we are now aware of. Him
snitching Horcrux from Voldemort does not look like saving his skin
first action to me, but more like heroic defiance a la Gryffindor
style.

I mean, it is possible of course that Regulus would be portrayed as
exception from Slytherin profile, just as Peter is an exception from
Gryffindor.
Just saying.

Sherry:
<SNIP>
If the story ends up that DD was
> dying or died from the potion in the cave, the potion that Harry
forced him
> to drink, and Snape faked the AK to cover that up, I'll want to
throw up.
> That would make Snape too heroic for me, and I'd be borrowing
lupinlore's
> wood chipper to destroy my audio and braille books. LOL.
<SNIP>


Alla:

Gah, I am weak Sherry. I would not be very happy of course if this
scenario would come true, even worse for me would be Heroic Noble
Martyr Snape revealing his true allegiances and making Harry to see
the light. As if the man did not torment him enough through the
books, I do not want to watch Harry humiliated and hurt again.
I mean, I know that he would be hurt by Voldemort again, that is for 
sure.

I don't want him being hurt by Snape again.


But, but, but the only way JKR would lose me as a reader ( and even
then I would not burn the books, just never come back to them and
certainly would not recommend them to the kids in my family - too
hopeless) would be if Harry dies.

If Snape is revealed as noble martyr, who killed DD on his orders,
well, I would just hope that Harry would move on with his life and
that his kids would never get the misfortune to have Snape in their
life.

I would hope that even if Snape is DD!M, Hogwarts would never ever
let the man who murdered one of the most beloved Headmaster back to
teaching.

In any event, I think happiness that Harry would survive his ordeals
would make it possible for me to overcome being sick if scenario you
described would come true.

Alla