The Snape Whisperer

[dumbledore11214]

No: HPFGUIDX 163560

> > Alla, who thinks that Dumbledore should be called a bloody 
> > hyppocrite if he deliberately employed this techinique with 
Harry, 
> > because he was one of the major contributors to Harry not 
getting 
> > the comfort through his life.
> >
> Carol responds:
> Oh, dear. It seems that each time someone tries to analyze or 
justify
> Dumbledore's behavior, you just become more angry with him. Maybe 
we'd
> better just hold our tongues, eh, Pippin, or Alla will change her
> Yahoo ID!
<BIG SNIP>

Alla:

Just to be clear since I was not clear whom you are implying I am 
angry with - Dumbledore or Pippin.

So, I am certainly angry with Dumbledore not with Pippin.
 
Carol:
<SNIP>
> Rather than considering Dumbledore a "bloody hypocrite" for 
employing
> a technique that we don't even know he's aware of, I think it 
might be
> better (more comforting :-) ) to return to regarding his treatment 
of
> Harry as a mistake rather than systematic cruelty. <SNIP>

Alla:

Um, yes, that was my point. That Dumbledore would look **much** 
better to me if what he did to Harry is not explained as some sort 
of technique, because then he looks to me as cruel bastard, and I 
would much prefer to think that this was his another mistake.


> Carol, just exploring Pippin's idea and wishing she could help Alla
> recover her lost affection for Albus Dumbledore
>

Alla:

Please don't help me.