Dumbledore's Secret 'All Along' Plan?
Penny Brooks
pennygbrooks at yahoo.com
Tue Jan 9 18:06:29 UTC 2007
No: HPFGUIDX 163632
I've enjoyed reading everyone's posts about Dumbledore, speculating on
how much he knew about LV, and when, and what his plans may have been
throughout the book series. (It's like Court TV.) I myself had been
of the mind that Dumbledore:
1) was aware of LV's existence, and his plans to reemerge
2) was aware of LV's thoughts about Harry, and the danger against Harry
3) had some idea about the horcruxes, and has been piecing together
the evidence since COS
But in my recent rereading of the books (for the hundredth time,
although with six books worth of information now, I guess I'm growing
more critical), certain questions are emerging--you all may have dealt
with them previously, but I did some searches and didn't find anything
conclusive.
1) Why would Dumbledore hire Lockhart? In COS, Dumbledore's comments
about him indicate he's fully aware of Lockhart's incapabilities. It's
hard to believe he hired him because no one else would do the job
(except Snape, of course). If you suspect that the most dangerous
wizard has a gripe with one of your students (a student you're fond of,
as well), why would you hire an incompetent to teach him (and the other
students) how to defend himself?
2) Why did Dumbledore agree to hold and host the Triwizard Tournament
at Hogwarts? It's known as a dangerous event in its own right, but if
you suspect that (again) the most dangerous wizard is still trying to
get into your school to take out a student, why would you allow the
state, and officials and students from other schools (including those
with dark pasts, like Karkaroff) free entry into your school? It's
hard to believe that he thought Moody by himself would be enough to
protect Harry and the other students.
I won't even go into the whole occlumency with Snape fiasco--even
Dumbledore admits it was a bad idea.
So, I'm wondering: if Dumbledore knew all along about LV's possible
plans and the horcruxes, and such, then either:
1) He's making a lot of inexplicable decisions
2) He's purposefully trying to get Harry to LV (oooh, a bad
Dumbledore. There have been worse ideas, I guess, but wouldn't that be
a twist--one that would have me shouting at my book 7, I'm afraid).
3) He was using Harry as bait to draw LV out, where the Order can get
him. Didn't work, but now Harry is old enough to handle things (maybe).
There must be more ideas. Any thoughts, anyone?
Penny Bee
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive