Maybe Snape really is DDM!
Chancie
chnc1024 at bellsouth.net
Wed Jan 10 01:29:05 UTC 2007
No: HPFGUIDX 163643
Chancie:
I read this quote that was written in the
"Dumbledore's secret plan all along"
Thread and it mad me think...
****************************************************************
bboyminn:
First, the DADA job has been in jeopardy for a long time.
We pick up the story when Harry arrives and see, so far,
six DADA teachers, each ending with his own bit of bad
luck.
However, you must remember that this curse on the DADA
job has been going on for over 20 years. It has been
curse from the time many many years ago when Voldemort
himself applied for the job. So, they have gone through
over 20 (estimate) DADA teachers, none has lasted more
than a year, and all have ended is some type of bad luck
or misfortune.
************************************************************
Chancie:
Jk has bombarded us with the "DADA teacher
position is cursed" thing from the first book. Could
she have meant this as a clue? I think we all find it
hard to believe that Dumbledore would actually
beg for his life. So maybe it's true that Dumbledore
was begging to be killed and that is Snape's punishment
from the curse. What I mean by that is if Snapes true
goal was to kill Dumbledore, wouldn't that have gone
against the curse? He would have gotten what he
wanted-that's not a curse that's a blessing! Does
that along with the other circumstantial evidence
PROVE that Snape is DDM?
Does that make any since or have the past few months
of no sleep finally made me loose my mind?
Chancie
[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive