Do you agree? (Harry as Horcrux)

[Steve]

No: HPFGUIDX 163729

--- , "Richie" <destinied6421_hao at ...> wrote:
>
> Hello, I'm a new member in this group, ..., I don't 
> know if this topic has been talked or not...
>

bboyminn:

Of course it has been talked about; over and over again,
but never fear, it is a topic that is still hotly debated.

> Richie:
>
> I think Harry might be also a Horcrux ....I believe
> Harry also a Horcrux because Harry has abilities that 
> comes from Voldemort himself since he tried to kill 
> Harry when he was a baby. ... So, tell me your opinion
> about it.
> Thank you.
> 
> Richie
>

bboyminn:

You will find lots and lots of people who agree with you;
I think I can safely say millions of people. However, there
is one glaring fact that prevents me from accepting the 
idea.

From what source do we know about Harry's scar connection
to Voldemort?
From Dumbledore.

>From what source do we know that Voldemort transferred
powers to Harry?
Dumbledore.

>From what source do we know all about the Horcruxes?
Dumbledore. 

Since it is Dumbledore who relays all our facts on this
matter to us, how could he not have considered the 
possibility? And if he did consider the possibility,
then, since he has not mentioned it, it would seem that
he discarded or discounted the idea.

If all-knowing Dumbledore doesn't think Harry is a 
Horcrux, then I don't see how I can. 

Of course, Dumbledore may have made a mistake, but that
is an extremely glaring mistake; an almost unbelievable
mistake.

Now, of course, I can not say whether Harry is or is not
a Horcrux. For that we will just have to wait and see.
And while you will certainly find millions of fans who
do agree with you, I will not be amoung them, though
I will happily eat my electrons if I am proven wrong.

Steve/bboyminn