[HPforGrownups] Re: Do you agree? (Harry as Horcrux)

[Scarah]

No: HPFGUIDX 163778

Geoff:
If all the Horcruxes have to be destroyed to finally dispose of Voldemort,
then this scenario dictates that Harry has to die - not might have to -
but has to.

Sarah:
OK, wait.  I hadn't been splitting any technical hairs up until this
point.  I'd just been thinking of it as "Harry Horcrux yeah blah
blah."

Are you only talking about people who believe that Harry's *whole
self* is a Horcrux?  Because I don't know anyone who thinks that.  It
seems pretty clearly geographically limited to the forehead area.  And
lots of people survive head surgery don't they?

I agree with Mike that it isn't necessary to believe that both (trying
for technical correctness here) there is a soul slice IN Harry
somewhere, AND that he will die.

Even though I think both, and that it is going to be awesome.  :)

Sarah