It really annoys me (but not me )

[eggplant107]

No: HPFGUIDX 163846

"justcarol67" <justcarol67 at ...> wrote:

> Black could have averted the whole fiasco
> by going to Dumbledore rather than seeking
> vigilante justice against Pettigrew 

Huh? Black was in Azkaban, everybody including Dumbledore thought he
was a mass murder; and Black was the only one who knew Pettigrew was
alive and had no way of proving it. It was either vigilante justice or
no justice at all. And I think Black could be forgiven for not having
a lot of faith in the Ministry, not after unjustly sentencing the poor
man to a living hell for 12 years! And remember, even Dumbledore
testified against him and helped send him to that hideous place.

> even if he were still only the gamekeeper's
> assistant, how could Molly not have 
> remembered seeing someone that big on the
> school grounds? 

Huh? Molly never said she don't remember Hagrid, she just said there
was another gamekeeper. 

> I'm annoyed by the inconsistencies, 
> particularly "the legendary Charlie Weasley."
> How can it be that Gryffindor has not won 
> the championship since Charlie left, which
> would be the year before SS/PS if he's the
> age JKR says he is (three years older 
> than Percy), yet they haven't won the cup 
> for seven straight years in both SS/PS and PoA 

No matter how good Charlie Weasley was he was only one man, he is not
a team. Look at Victor Crumb at the World Cup, he was by far the best
player on either side, but his team still lost. As one of the twins
said, Romania had one good player, Ireland had 7. Ireland won,
although it must be admitted Romania lost in a very classy way.

Eggplant