Newbie theory - Harry at Godric's Hollow

[julie]

No: HPFGUIDX 163858

--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, plantlady Angie 
<plantladywithcfids at ...> wrote:
>
> I love this theory, what does everyone else think?
>    
>   "Harry finds a time turner in Godric Hollows and uses it to go 
back in time to the night of his parents death.   There he sees the 
truth about what really happened and it turns out that it is he who 
was the other person there that night.  Harry tells DD about what 
happens and that is how DD knows exactly what to do with the baby and 
why he is so elusive about telling Harry any more than he absolutely 
has too.   Also remember when Snape first sees Harry in the first 
book and movie, he has kind of a surprised expression on his face.  
What if he knows Harry was there that night?   Also this trip back in 
time gives Harry what he needs to finally end LV rein over the 
darkness once and for all."
>    
>   Angie

Julie:
Lord, I hope you're wrong! Sorry, while I don't mind how the time-
turner was used in POA, I really don't want to see it used again. 
It's too easy a fix, especially as we've already seen Harry save his 
younger self once. Not again please. 

OTOH, JKR did say something about the time-turner resurfacing :-( If 
it does, I can accept it if it helps explain why Dumbledore had to be 
so careful about what and how much information he revealed to Harry 
(anything that keeps Dumbledore's character from being the cold-
hearted, manipulative bastard many fans see right now works for me). 
And just so long as it doesn't a major role in resolving the plot. 

Julie