Do you agree? (Harry as Horcrux)

[JULIA WILKES]

No: HPFGUIDX 163930

Geoff:
> In my reply, I was commenting on the view expressed by some
> contributors that the scar WAS a Horcrux, not merely a portal.
> This would have implied that the encased soul fragment was being
> held close to Harry's head, hence my concern about a potential 
> threat to his health.
 
> I rather see the soul in this context as being rather like a volume
> of gas contained in a closed container. If some is removed, the 
> amount of gas present is less but expands to fill the volume 
> available.
 
> Geoff
> Still believing that Harry is really a Noncrux.
 
 
     
Geoff,
I do not believe Harry is a Horcrux either.  I think LV is a little smarter than that. Though it is believed that LV may have made the snake, Nagini, a Horcrux, I think LV knows that to make a human/wizard a Horcrux, someone who can think for him self and act for himself would be a major mistake but with Nagini he does have control of her.  Do you think Harry will truly kill LV... is capable of killing of LV.  I am not convinced he is capable at this age nor skilled enough so I wonder if in the last book if the "BIG FIGHT" will not take place 5 maybe even 10 yrs down the road.  Or will he have a change of heart, as with Wormtail, and want something else for him.  What do you think of him erasing his memory, as with  Professor Lockhart?

Julie W.