Could Dumbledore have got the invisiblity cloak on the night the Potters died.

lone_white_werewolf lone_white_werewolf at yahoo.co.uk
Fri Jan 19 17:16:52 UTC 2007


No: HPFGUIDX 163946

An invisibility cloak would be a useful thing when hiding, even under
Fidelius, so perhaps James had it on him the night he died, but when
Voldemort came and he told Lilly to run he gave her the cloak and she
passed it on to an invisible Dumbledore.

This could explain how Dumbledore knew about the house collapsing, and
also how he knew about Lilly's sacrifice, he mentioned it in PS,
however Harry didn't recall what happened until POA.

Before you argue that Dumbledore would then know Peter was the secret
keeper, couldn't Peter have written a note, like Dumbledore in OOTP, in
a disguised hand and have someone give it to Dumbledore.

Also didn't JKR say that there is an important reason that Dumbledore
got the cloak, perhaps the fact that he was at Godric Hollow would be
important?

lone_white_werewolf




More information about the HPforGrownups archive