It really annoys me (but not me )

[zgirnius]

No: HPFGUIDX 163969


> zgirnius:
> 
> Alternatively, if the Boggart can sense when it is being seen, it
> turned into Moody's Boggart, and that is something one would not 
find
> hiding in a piece of furniture, even at the Black house.
> 
> Lynda:
> 
> Now that's an interesting assumption. It seems to me that a boggart 
would
> feel extremely ..."comfortable" in a house like the Black's. Dark, 
full of
> creepy things. Inhabited by people (for many years) who are, 
dedicated to
> the dark arts.

zgirnius:
I am not assuming that a boggart would feel uncomfortable, I agree it 
would.

Actually, I am not assuming much at all. I am suggesting that since 
Moody knew it was a boggart, what he saw when he looked at it was 
either 1) a boggart in its natural (supposedly unknown) form, or 2) 
the shape Boggarts habitually take for Moody. Now, if whatever that 
is, belongs in 12 GP, how could Moody know it was a Boggart, and 
not...whatever? So I conclude that if the Boogart took a form for 
Moody, that form is not something that would tyoically hide out in a 
piece of furniture at 12 GP. 

I hope I am clearer, this time around...I blame it on the nasty virus 
I caught from the kiddies. <g>