[HPforGrownups] Re: The two-way mirror - a cruel useless plot device

[Jeremiah LaFleur]

No: HPFGUIDX 163989

>Lana
>I just get pricklies when I think about it, so I have this nagging feeling
we have missed something in the books that will come out to play with the
mirror. Not sure what it is that could have been missed, but there is
something I think.. LOL

Nikkalmati

Do we have any idea where the other mirror is? Of course, Harry broke his,
but I am sure it can be repaired. If Sirius was in the habit of carrying it
around with him, he may have had it on him when he went through the Veil. If

that is true and Harry goes through the Veil at some point (see Carol
possession theory), he may leave the mirror he has with one of the friends
and once
he finds Sirius' body, he then can communicate back to the friend with the
mirror Sirius had in his pocket.

Nikkalmati
------------------------------------

Jeremiah:

It is unknown if Sirius went through the veil with the mirror. If he did
then would sirius be able to respod to Harry's calls at the end of OotP? IMO
I don't think that he would. The morror is a physical object and he moved to
a plane where you are nolonger physical, but then again, where is Sirius'
body? I think that's the Mystery, now isn't it?

I disagree with Nikkalmati's theory about posession, but that's the fun of
this board. :) I do, however, think that the Dept of Mysteries will be a
portion of the final book but I have no idea how... It's possible that
someone might need a time-turner, or Ron has to confront the "inner" scars
from the brain, or that the Veil will be revisited... but for what reasons I
cannot imagine as of right now.

(jeremiah is currently marking up his freshly purchased paperbacks and hopes
to find some interresting clue or fact that he has not discovered as of
right now.)


[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]