[HPforGrownups] Re: POA movie clues to book 7 solutions

[Jeremiah LaFleur]

No: HPFGUIDX 163991

> >>katssirius wrote:
>> Over the holidays I watched the POA movie again.
>> <snip>
>> I was interested to note the lake scene when the dementors attack Harry
and Sirius. One soul is being sucked out of Sirius while two souls are being
sucked out of Harry. This provides more evidence for the Harry as horcrux
theory as well as that it is possible to remove one soul separately from the
other.<< <snip>

Mitchell:
I've read seen and heard OVER AND OVER again the possibility that Harry
is a horcrux. But I just can't buy into it. Not with Voldemort constantly
trying to kill Harry! If He's gone though SO MUCH EFFORT to guard and
protect his soul fragments, why would he kill Harry knowing he'd be
destroying a part of himself?

----------------------------
Jeremiah:

I agree with Mitchell. I see no reason for Voldemort to have tried to make
Harry a Horcrux if LV intended to kill Harry. The accidental theory sounds
better in this light but from what Slughorn said the spell would be
complicated. But knowing that LV was going to murder Harry then LV may have
inteded to use the murder to create one.

But I would think that LV, being in his 60's by this time would have already
made all of them.

And that's my opinion on why Harry is not a Horcrux. (But I could be wrong).


[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]