Another McGonagall theory (was Re: ESE!McGonagall (not what you think))

[CLAUDIA]

No: HPFGUIDX 164278

> laperchette:
> <snip>
> ... it has to be someone important.  It wouldn't be fun to
> hear Vector or Sinistra (or another minor character) is a
> traitor, that wouldn't be interesting, it has to be someone
> we feel attached to. It cannot be a kid, because it has to
> go back to Godric Hollow-times.  <snip> it cannot be Lupin
> or Hagrid (the message: don't trust halfgiants and werewolfs
> (eg people with problems) would be a bit awkward and not
> typical for Rowling).  So there are only McGonagall, Flitwitch
> and Sprout left. The shock of ESE!McGonagall would be the
> biggest.  <snip>


Well, here is my own little theory about McGonagall. Is it
possible that it's more simpler than everyone is thinking? Maybe
DD never confided in McGonagall because of the same reasons why
Lupin doesn't want to be with Tonks and Harry broke up with
Ginny. Is it possible that DD was in love with McGonagall? The
more she knew, the more danger she was in. I know that this
theory is way out there, but still possible.

Why were DD, McGonagall, and LV still single after all these yrs?
Well LV was obvious, how can someone so evil ever know love. But
for DD and McGonagall, maybe there was a spark there that no one
ever noticed. Is it possible?

Claudia