Did Grindelwald create a Horcrux?
jmwcfo
jmwcfo at yahoo.com
Sun Jul 1 20:55:33 UTC 2007
No: HPFGUIDX 171103
> > Cassy:
> > I'm wondering if we know (or have a good idea) that Grindelwald
created a
> > horcrux...
> > someone mentioned on here that one other wizard has created
one... did JKR
> > say that
> > someone other than VD had created one? If so, I think the
assumption that
> > it was
> > Grindelwald would be correct.
> >
>
> Cassy:
> I'm fairly sure that cannon does NOT mention any Grindewald
horcruxes, or
> actually anything about Grindewald, save the fact that Dumbledore
defeted
> him. Well, Slughorn was talking about how horcruxes are usually
created, so,
> naturally, *someone* had to create them before, but we don't know
who
> exactly. It could have been, say, Salazar.
JW:
In the cemetery scene, LV says words to the effect that he "has gone
FURTHER than any other wizard has in achieving immortality." DD's
interprestation is that LV is the first to create MULTIPLE
horcruxes. I have a vague recollection that JKR has said that
Grindelwald did indeed create a single horcrux. Presumably, either
DD knew of this and destroyed it to defeat G, or else the existence
of the horcrux did not prevent DD from defeating G.
Please note that DD DEFEATED G. I assume this is different from
KILLING him. So what ever happened to him?
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive