Harry's scar, love, and the death of Voldemort

[karen]

No: HPFGUIDX 171547

Karen:
> > > 1) Harry's scar is a Horcrux
> > > CoS- "Voldemort put a bit of himself in me?" Harry said, 
> > thuderstruck.
> > > "It certainly seems so." (DD)

Miss Vassy: Up until I saw the movie last night (free preview), I 
thought Harry 
> might be a horcrux.  There was nothing specific in the movie that 
> made me change my mind, but it was different seeing the occlumency 
on 
> screen rather than just reading about it and envisioning it in my 
> mind.  I no longer think he is a horcrux.  I think that if Harry 
was 
> truly a horcrux, Snape would have seen some of Voldemort's memories 
> too when he was doing the occlumency lessons.  If a bit of Voldy's 
> soul was in Harry, I don't think Voldy would be able to control 
> whether or not Harry revealed some memories to Snape.  Even 
> Dumbledore says, when telling Harry he thinks Nagini might be a 
> horcrux, that there is a risk in making a horcrux out of something 
> that can think and act for itself.  I believe Harry's ability to 
see 
> what Voldy was thinking, it was only because there is a link from 
the 
> scar and moreso from the blood that Voldy took from Harry in the 
> graveyard. 

Karen: I know it's very difficult to make a horcrux but it almost 
seems that throughout the books, when the scar is talked about, that 
LV doesn't realize how much power he really gave Harry.  It's almost 
as if he perhaps created the horcrux by mistake in Harry as it was 
intended to be in someone else... idk- it's just a feeling I get.  I 
really am not sure he meant to put it in a thing that can "think and 
act for itself".