Dementors and Horcrux-sucking

[Eddie]

No: HPFGUIDX 171559

The many theories that involve Dementors sucking bits of Voldemort's
soul out of Horcrux(es) is flawed, I think.  Just because the bit of
soul is Dementor-sucked doesn't necessarily mean that the bit of soul
no longer works as it did inside the Horcrux object.  The soul bit may
have moved from a locket (for example) to inside a Dementor tummy, but
the soul bit is still around. Right?

Eddie