Bizarre Take on Snape & Harry's Relationship

Cathy SnowyHome at aol.com
Wed Jul 18 19:41:06 UTC 2007


No: HPFGUIDX 172132

I just posted this thought on the HPFS's List and wondered if anyone here had a similar bizarre thought like this.  Is it possible that Snape raped Lily in the past and that Harry is Snape's son and not James' son?  I know this idea has shades of Darth Vadar being Luke Skywalker's father in "Star Wars" but it popped into my head as they kept saying on the A & E special "Hidden Secrets of Harry Potter" that no one in Harry Potter is how they seem to be when we first read about them.  I know its a bizarre thought and I think Harry Potter fever is at a frenzy now that we are only 3 days away from the ending so this
thought just came up.  Has anyone here considered this?

Cathy






More information about the HPforGrownups archive