Bizarre Take on Snape & Harry's Relationship

[sk8maven]

No: HPFGUIDX 172144





> > Cathy wrote:
> <SNIP>
> > > Is it possible that Snape raped Lily in the past and that
> > > Harry is Snape's son and not James' son?
>
--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, "Sue" <red-siren at ...> wrote:
> James would have killed Snape if he'd raped Lily. Besides, I
> don't think JKR would introduce that kind of story content into
> what is essentially a children's book. There's enough evil going
> on as is.

There's SOMEthing between Snape and Lily, I have no doubt. But it
isn't THAT. IMHO Snape was hopelessly, unrequitedly in love with Lily
- and he's so unable to deal fairly with Harry not merely because he
looks so much like his father (whom Snape hated), but he also "has his
mother's eyes" (and brings back all that old frustration and stifled
grief).

Maven