Kreacher and Dobby switched!

[smartone564]

No: HPFGUIDX 172224

I was talking with my girlfriend about DH last night, and she
explained to me how Dobby and Kreacher should have reversed their
roles.  HRH just leave Kreacher to defend himself against the DEs who
are likely to show up without so much as a warning.  How hard would it
have been to call for him, warn him, and then let him return home to
defend it?  I know they were worried about DEs apparating with him,
but how hard could it be for all three of them to overpower the one or
two DEs likely to be touching Kreacher right then?  It's not like they
haven't done it time and time again.  Also, Kreacher should've been
the one to show up at the Malfoy's and save Harry and co. from there,
dying as a fully redeemed character, saving his master as a house elf
does.  Then in the end, it's fits perfectly for Dobby to be leading
the charge of the Hogwarts House elves, since he actually worked there
and was familiar with them, etc.  

I like this ending so much better I think I might just pretend it's
the actual ending, even though I cried for Dobby as soon as I saw the
knife sticking out of him.  Still thought the book was awesome though.

Toner