Harry lives... OK?

-jme- jmestacio at yahoo.com
Tue Jul 24 20:41:32 UTC 2007


No: HPFGUIDX 172246


Geoff Bannister a écrit :
> I am left breathless by the book but we must remember the words of
> the Duke of Wellington about Waterloo that it was "a damned close-
> run" thing. We lost a lot of good people... I wonder whose loss
> affected you most?

Vincent said:
Lupin and Tonks, definitely.
Fred was kind of "expected," when we see him joking with Percy, it
clearly was a now-someone's-gonna-be-out-pretty-soon-moment, but Lupin and Tonks, that was so unexpected, we don't even know how they died, they just are killed, just like that.

That's what got me really heartbroken

argentumangela says:
Dobby's death was the one that opened the waterworks for me. I couldn't believe what happened to him.  His death was symbolic of the extent of how everyone was affected by Voldy's propaganda. It was such an innocent life wasted. And totally unexpected.







"Fairytales are are more than real. Not because they tell us that dragons exist but because they tell us that they can be defeated." [GK Chesterton]





More information about the HPforGrownups archive