Snape, mostly (was:Re: My Officially First Deathly Hallows Post!!)

[klmtapir]

No: HPFGUIDX 172350

> Reed:

> First of all, it was way too long. The kid scenes were much too
> drawn out and gave little necessary information (the whole Petunia
> thing has no purpose in Snapes memories, in my opinion. It should
> better have been addressed at the beginning, before the Dursleys
> leave).


I think that was mainly put in as a callback to (I believe) OoTP -- I
don't have the book with me, but I'm pretty sure Petunia says she
heard about the Dementors when she overheard Lily talking to "that
awful boy". We were meant to assume, like Harry did, that the awful
boy was James, but many suspected that it was actually Snape. Good
call.



klmtapir, previously:
>> Victoire is still at Hogwarts, but Teddy is apparently all finished
>> up. And a cradle-robber.


>Anne Squires;
>
>A cradle robber? Come on, a nineteen yr old with a seventeen yr old
>isn't a cradle robber.


Sorry, I forgot the seventeen smileys and LMAOs and ROFLs and LOLs that would have indicated that I was kidding.

:^)  :^)

klmtapir