[HPforGrownups] Re: Harry/new member

Denise Leblanc denisewcr at yahoo.com
Tue Jul 24 22:24:16 UTC 2007


No: HPFGUIDX 172363

Hi I just joined 2 days ago hoping to discuss the book as my son in 
the beginning of the book, work is getting in the way. 

I loved the book but was upset at Hedwig and Dobby. I feel Harry 
lost so much and to lose the one thing that helped him out while 
at the Dursleys was heart breaking. I have some  parrots and felt 
his pain, to just think of losing any of mine would hurt. 

Snape was a surprise but I felt he was good all along. A coworker 
feels he new he would die in the end and wanted to due to the loss 
of Lily. I wish he could have said something to Harry before he 
passed. What about the eyes no explanation but she still mentions 
them! 

Who used magic late in life?

I think she killed of to many she is a little fixated on death! 
Plus she didn't go into enough of life after the war. Did 
Neville's parents ever get better? Jobs? Did Harry go to live 
in the house left to him or rebuild his parent's house? So many 
more.

Denise




More information about the HPforGrownups archive