[HPforGrownups] Snape, mostly (was:Re: My Officially First Deathly Hallows Post!!)

doliesl at yahoo.com doliesl at yahoo.com
Tue Jul 24 22:55:44 UTC 2007


No: HPFGUIDX 172378


Reed:
<Well, I was always firmly in the Snape-is-not-evil camp and I am okay
with Snape-loves-Lily in principle and expected it, but nevertheless I
must say, I wholeheartedly agree with everything you say about Chapter
33. It was *awful* - not in the idea, but in the way to present it.

And how GOOD! Even George's ear was just an *accident*.
Pleeease! It was all so into your face that I cringed the whole chapter.>

D:
Because even being so 'in your face' some people still  miss it, they still think Snape is evil who had no moral inside and can't tell right from wrong. The George's ear's accident was one of the many important example of Snape changed from that 'only care for Lily nor others' man to the noble man who risk everything to do the right thing, to save people, NOT for personal purpose. That scene is there for a reason. 

I love LOVE LOVE Snape ever more after Book 7! He's truly the best character of the series! 
I feel so vindicated for sticking with Snape all along. 

It was so sweet Harry named his son (THE one who looks most like him with Lily's eyes~) after Snape, as if Snape reincarnated as Harry's son.  And the "THE bravest man he's ever known" was practically the little 'bouya' of the whole seemingly too sweet/pointlessly mundane epilogue.  I knew it, it IS all about Snape in the end. :DDDD

D.






[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]





More information about the HPforGrownups archive