First Comments on HP:DH

[seanmulligan2000]

No: HPFGUIDX 172509

--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, "Jenni Merrifield"
<SNIP>
> e.	Not one Slytherin student stayed behind to fight or even
returned during the second wave with the Hogsmead villagers.  I
really expected to see at least a few who knew that fighting
Voldemort was the right thing to do and were willing to choose the
right way not the easy way.


seanmulligan2000:
That was my biggest dissapointment as well. It seemed that Rowlings
was confirming stereotypes of Slytherins as the Death Eater House,
although I don't remember if she said that none of the Slytherins
fought for Hogwarts.  Some of them might have fought for the light
and were but they were just not mentioned.