the peverell's hallows

james black potter seusilva at uol.com.br
Wed Jul 25 02:32:19 UTC 2007


No: HPFGUIDX 172515

I tend to agree with Dumbledore, when he says that the Hallows were human made. Powerfull they are, but far from perfect.

The Wand - Dumbledore beat Grindelwald (to say the least)
The Stone - it does not really bring back dead people
The Cloak - 'Mad-Eye' was able to see (in some sense*) through it (of course, his eye was also an unique artifact)**

(*) Harry thought that Mad-Eye was able to see him properly, but that might not be the case (Fake Moody even says: "nice cloak you have there" etc)
(**) we must consider also that Harry was not using it for most noble purposes on that night

	james black potter





More information about the HPforGrownups archive