Nagini and the Invisibililty Cloak - thoughts?

[irenetsui]

No: HPFGUIDX 172717


>
> On 7/25/07, doppioprego <doppioprego at ...> wrote:
> >
> >  In Godric's Hollow, Nagini (as Bathilda) was able to see,
recognise and
> >  beckon Harry to come into the house, despite the fact he and Hermione
> >  were under the cloak AND disguised as a middle-aged couple. In the
> >  Shrieking Shack during the Voldemort/Snape showdown she is shown is
> >  floating around in the bubble whilst Snape repeatedly asks Voldy
> >  to 'let me bring you the boy'. Why would Nagini not have spotted
Harry
> >  hiding under the cloak and told Voldy of this? Would have spared an
> >  awful lot of time and magical effort in destroying the Hogwarts
castle
> >  to root him out.
> 

Irene:

At that time, Harry was still inside the tunnel, underneath a crate.
He was not standing blatantly in the room, under the cloak. Nagini did
not see him.