Deathly Hallows Reaction - Could do Better, Sorry

saxifrage_ camckenzie at yahoo.com
Wed Jul 25 20:31:08 UTC 2007


No: HPFGUIDX 172782

>Goddlefrood says:
 Dumbledore's back story I did like, it made a great
> deal of sense. He could quite easily have mentioned
> that Horcruxes are not too difficult to destroy, as
> they ultimately proved. That information seemed to me
> to have been withheld for no especially good reason
> before its revelation from the book Hermione had
> summoned.

As I was reading your post, this just occurred to me.  The whole "horcruxes are difficult to 
destroy" is a giant red herring laid temptingly in our paths.  After HBP, most of us think that 
DD's blackened, dead hand came from destroying the Horcrux.  Actually, it was from his 
lapse in judgement in trying to use the resurrection stone.  Much of the fun of good fiction is 
that we don't see everything coming and we are led to misinterpret things.

-WeasleyWannaB





More information about the HPforGrownups archive