inconsistency?

ballycrehane ambogorman at eircom.net
Wed Jul 25 21:36:18 UTC 2007


No: HPFGUIDX 172808

Laura Lindsay:
> > Still catching up on all posts-- forgive if this is a repeat,
> > but how on earth did DD beat Grindelwald in the duel if Gr had
> > an _unbeatable_ wand??? Isn't that what they say the whole point
> > was of the elder wand: It can't be eaten in a duel?

Valky:
> Yep you're right, but I don't think there can be any question that
> if anyone could figure out a way *around* an unbeatable wand it
> would be Dumbledore.  I figure he didn't try to beat the wand at all
> and cleverly figured a way to bypass the wand and overcome
> Grindelwald himself by some means during the battle.



Just thinking. Maybe DD used expelliarmus? It's what Draco used to
get the wand and then it would have been easy for DD to finish
Grindelwald off. Auntie Muriel, unreliable gossip though she may be,
did say that Grindelwald surrendered easily.

lala







More information about the HPforGrownups archive