Unforgivables.

pwrmom2 jenlundq at hotmail.com
Thu Jul 26 11:55:01 UTC 2007


No: HPFGUIDX 172958

Charlie:
> I'm sorry,
> but it seems that those people are the type that believe Rita
> Skeeter's stuff over everything else in the books.
>
> Charles, who hates the Ministry and their sodding laws.
>

Pwrmom2:
I agree with Charles, there is a difference between using the
unforgivables for good and evil.  Sadly this was a state of war for
them.  there have been so many posts I haven't been able to read
them all so forgive me if I'm repeating something already said.
Think of murder.  Against the law in most if not all countries, yet
all of these countries have exceptions when it comes to war.  It
comes to a point where it is kill or be killed, use an UC or have
one done to you.  When in a high stress situation having AV thrown
at you, I think it would be hard to sit and think or what other
curse to use instead and hope no one undoes the curse or they come
out of it and AV you.  It's kill or be killed, Use the imperius
curse to help you get at the horocrux that will help rid the world
of evil and in this way still be not harming the DE who would as
soon kill you as look at you...etc.
   War is ugly and I think that is part of what JKR was showing.  In
a war state people are doing things they would never have imagined
doing prior to this state, but they have family members and friends
being killed, and other innocents (ie the Muggles who were being
killed without even knowing the WW exists).





More information about the HPforGrownups archive