Victory for TEWWW EWWW

Adesa homeboys at comcast.net
Thu Jul 26 17:20:49 UTC 2007


No: HPFGUIDX 173031


> colebiancardi:
>>SNIP<<
> What type of message is that? I guess JKR is cementing the idea that
> Snape did not mature in the last 16 years since Lily's death. That
> there is nothing but Lily. That was my rant earlier about the lack 
of
> personal growth & maturity and making atones and moving on. She
> doesn't give certain characters that possibility, based on that
> interview this morning.
> 
> not pleased at all.

Adesa:
But do people really experience personal growth and atonement 
throughout their adult lives? Sure, many do. But there *are* people 
who get stuck in adolescence, people whose obsessions never go away, 
people who neither forgive nor seek forgiveness, people who never get 
their act together. There really are people like that in the world, 
to varying degrees. That you and I and most people we know have grown 
emotionally since our young adulthood doesn't mean *everyone* has. 
And those who haven't have my sympathy -- but I wouldn't want to 
spend time with them. I find Snape to be very believable, though 
thoroughly unlikable.





More information about the HPforGrownups archive