Victory for TEWWW EWWW

[Dana]

No: HPFGUIDX 173137

SSSusan:
> And I would mention that, unless a reread of this section shows me 
> something I've missed, Snape gave Harry *more* of the truth than DD 
> himself ever did.  
> 
> DD did *not* share his belief that Harry would need to die -- or at 
> least that the soul bit within him would have to, because he didn't 
> tell Harry about that soul bit -- which means, imo, that Harry was 
> not fully informed about what choice he was facing.  As I've said 
> before, to me that means his choice was less of real choice.  SNAPE 
> gave him the whole picture, all the information Harry wanted (and 
> had asked for in the past) and needed if he were to be able to make 
> a fully-informed choice. 
<snip> 

Dana:
Just for argument sake. What if Snape did not give the memory to 
Harry so he could go kill himself but that it was a last attempt of 
Snape to keep Lily's sacrifice high? For this Snape would need Harry 
to see that what he did was all for Lily, so her son could live but 
DD wanted to sacrifice Harry for the greater good? Snape does not 
know that the wand was not rightfully his. He doesn't know that LV 
with this specific wand is not now more powerful then Harry could 
ever imagine and that the boy's hours are numbered. (Snape never 
thought much of Harry anyway and thinks in his last moment that LV 
with this wand will be unbeatable) So instead of wanting Harry to 
march of to his death he actually wanted to safe Harry's life one 
more time. Snape did not know that Harry had a lot more information 
and understanding of what he was supposed to do with the information 
that DD wanted Snape to give to Harry. 

Snape then wants to look at Lily's eyes one more time before he dies 
believing he has done the last final deed to keep Lily Potter's son 
safe and not let her sacrifice be in vain. 

Just a thought 

Dana