Questions for JKR

[Annemehr]

No: HPFGUIDX 173243

 
> Dungrollin:
> 
> How about this for an inconsistency:
> Why didn't Voldemort become the master of the Elder wand when he AKed 
> Harry in the forest? 
> 
> Because he didn't kill him? DD didn't kill Grindelwald, either, 
> neither did Harry kill Malfoy. Needs some bending over backwards to 
> wriggle out of IMO.


Well, if Harry's correct in his explanation to LV in the Great Hall, 
Snape would never have become master of the wand by killing DD, because 
he would not have *defeated* DD; it was something they planned between 
them.

I think a very similar reason would apply when LV AKed Harry in the 
Forest: it wasn't a defeat of Harry, because it's what Harry wanted for 
him to do.

Annemehr,
still trying to work out exactly what she said...