JKR Cut Ron & Hermione Like a Movie Edit ...UNbelievable! ?

[Adesa]

No: HPFGUIDX 173340

--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, "KathyK" <zanelupin at ...> wrote:
>
> Sara wrote:
> > My criticism is that JKR should have placed some believable 
> > storyline where Ron & Hermione were forced to allow Harry to go 
on 
> > alone without any other choice or option they could have taken.  
> > Even a physical barrier or blocking mechanism would have 
sufficed, 
> > though a fully reasoned approach would have enhanced the story 
> > wonderfully for many interpretive standpoints of why Harry had to 
go 
> > on alone without them.  

>>SNIP<<


> KathyK:
> 
> I'm sorry but I'm quite certain that it was *Harry* who slipped off
> and "abandoned" Ron and Hermione (if you want to look at things that
> way).  And Harry going it alone is not at all out of character, 
IMO. 

>>SNIP<<

Adesa:

And let's not forget our ever-practical witch friend. I find it 
totally in-character for Hermione to realize they needed those fangs, 
not see Harry around, and rush off to get them awhile without him. 
I'm sure she was thinking, "Well, what'll he do once he's got the 
Horcruxes and Voldemort in front of him?" Always planning ahead, she 
is, unlike our hero.