Alternate book ending

[Alice Franceschini]

No: HPFGUIDX 173462

I have been reprimanded about the way I post.  Guess I am doing it
wrong but I have re-read the rules and hoping this posting will be
correct.  I post to a number of various subjected boards like this
and this by far is the hardest board to post to for me.

Today's posting is about the 7th book so I think I am ok to post here.  I am sure you will let me know if I still have it wrong, lol.

As I have pondered the seventh book I think I would like an alternate
ending book.  Think about it, so much death and for what? Rowling said she really thinks about the characters she kills but it doesn't read like that in this 7th book to me.  It seems like she killed for the shock value and not all that concerned about the story line.  Rowling claims differently of course.

This 7th book leaves me in a constant state of unfinished business.  There is no satisfaction to it.  It leaves me hallow.  I am sorry I got involved. It makes me want to throw out the books and movies Because it has hurt my re-reading of the previous books now when it  comes to Fred, Hedwig, Snape and others. The movies too. It basically has ruined all my affection for the Harry Potter series.

Why kill Hedwig?  Why Dobby?  There isn't an 8th book so there isn't a plot line to protect.  I mean if you look at all the characters Rowling killed in the 7th book do you see any benefit to the story line as to why?  Why kill Lupin and Tonks, because they were happy?  And what happened to their baby?  See, a lot of unfinished business and the book series has ended.  Don't feel right to me.

Lady Potions



**Elfy Reminder** Please post comments about list policy or procedure at the HPFGU Feedback group:

http://groups.yahoo.com/group/HPFGU-Feedback/