Too quick and a sell out

Alice Franceschini ladypotentpotions1 at yahoo.com
Sat Jul 28 15:49:59 UTC 2007


No: HPFGUIDX 173464

Carla:
<snip>
> Does anyone else feel this way?  Empty deaths for shock and
> effect....no back stories to explain the over simplified plot
> devices.  The previous 6 books were brilliant.  Did she grow so tired
> of Harry and those we love so much that she just did whatever to get
> away from it?  I hear she cried. Well so did those dedicated fans who
> expected the same thoughtfulness, consideration, and love that the
> other books contained.  There better be one hell of an epilogue to
> make up for the shabby treatment of the characters I've come to love
> and cherish so much.  This book hurt my heart.  It's like losing
> friends for no other cause but financial gain.  Nothing noble there.
> And to me, these characters were noble.



Oh Carla I feel just like you do !!!!  The 7th book leaves me in a
state of unfinished business and has hurt my re-reading the previous
books.  I agree, there should have been another book, this 7th book
which was suppose to tie up all the loose ends, made more questions
than it answered.  I do feel this book was rushed and a sell out.

Just my 2 dents,
Lady Potions





More information about the HPforGrownups archive