The mirror, parents, Black and Dumbledore

Alice Franceschini ladypotentpotions1 at yahoo.com
Sat Jul 28 16:39:36 UTC 2007


No: HPFGUIDX 173474

I was just reading someone's post (sorry don't recall the name) asking about the moral part of the series.

I was sure that in the 7th book Harry because of his
bravery he would get one chance to look in that mirror
or that thing that Black fell into and get to choose only
one of them to come back to life.  Real living and not with
that veil between them.

Which one would Harry choose and why?
His mom, dad, Black or Dumbledore - someone else?
This is what I thought the whole series was going to lead to.
Than after Harry finally chose only one, Death appears to Harry and
says he will restore life to all the people and animals\elves
that Harry sees in the mirror, IF Harry returns to him all of the
Deathly Hallows - the Elder Wand, The Tiara and the Invisible Cloak.
This is why I thought Rowlings killed off the characters
the way she did.  But to find out she killed them off for shock
value or because she had a deadline to meet is really disheartening to me.

I doubt I will get involved in another series of books if she writes
them unless she wrote an alternate book.  I doubt I will attend
anymore movies.

Lady Potions










More information about the HPforGrownups archive