Slytherins are not Jews...

doddiemoemoe doddiemoemoe at yahoo.com
Sun Jul 29 05:18:31 UTC 2007


No: HPFGUIDX 173568

Nor are they hindi's, Sikh's, or anything else besides somesort of 
christian religion...seeing as they always take Christmas and Easter 
holiday's...make appearances(aside from Draco) for holiday feasts...

Also during hogsmead weekends they never go to temple on 
Saturday..nor are Saturday or Sundays mentioned for the most part in 
the entire series...nor during Ramadon to we hear of fasting for any 
members of staff(any Jew would probably notice)..

I'm guessing hogsmeade weekends happen on saturdays...yet everyone 
seems to go.(perhaps Jewish witches and wizards attend kosher school 
in jeruslalem?)...would be a different feasting table...as meat is 
butchered in another fashion...

And most quidditch matches occurr on saturdays in cannon.

Besides which...if all slytherins are jews(which I doubt as Jews had 
been around thousands of years before hogwarts)...how can you 
explain that they celebrate Halloween, Christmas, and easter(among a 
few)...but not any Jewish holidays--the big one being 
roshashana...or even muslims cellebrating ramadan..

DeeDEe





More information about the HPforGrownups archive