Slapstick Comedy

[zanooda2]

No: HPFGUIDX 173914

--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, Kathryn Jones <kjones at ...> wrote:

>> Zanooda writes:

>> As Aberforth has the second (Sirius') part of the mirror (he 
>> bought it from Mundungus), who else's eye can Harry see there? 
 
> KJ writes:
 
> I find it pretty darn hard to believe that Aberforth bought 
> everything from Mundungus.


I agree that there are lots of inconsistencies in the book, but I don't 
think Sirius's mirror is one of them. Aberforth buying the mirror is 
not a theory, it's from the book. Harry saw the mirror at "Hog's Head" 
and Aberforth told him he bought it from Dung (p.559-560).