Dumbledore the Godfather

[eggplant107]

No: HPFGUIDX 173932

allies426 wrote:

> DD misled Snape because Harry
> had to TRULY THINK he was 
> walking to his death 

Huh? So Dumbledore figured out that Snape would die, and he figured
out that Harry would be there when he died, and he figured out that
Harry would capture his last memories, and he figured out Harry would
find a way to read them, and he figured out Harry would be profoundly
effected by it? And Dumbledore figured out that Harry wouldn't die
whatever he did? I'm sorry but that's just nuts. Face it, Dumbledore
was being cold blooded, and being cold blooded is exactly what the
world needed at that time. I love Harry as much as anyone, but better
he die than the entire wizard world.  

> If Harry can forgive DD, then I can

OK, I cannot deny that is a good point. That is a very VERY good
point! Dumbledore had his faults there is absolutely no doubt about
it; but the next time some mega evil villain tries to take over the
universe I'd still like Dumbledore to be in charge of the resistance !  

Eggplant Gellert Grindelwald