Prank and various responsibilities WAS: Re: Marietta

[colebiancardi]

No: HPFGUIDX 169674

 
> colebiancardi:
> <SNIP of the almost whole post>
> > Hagrid would have killed himself if the Trio had been killed by
> > Fluffy.  Sirius would have been overjoyed if Snape had died at the
> > hands of Lupin.  And Sirius didn't give a second thought about how
> > Lupin would feel about this matter afterwards.
> 
> 
> Alla:
> 
> I agree with many differences you pointed out that Hagrid was not 
> planning any trap, but here we hit my " we do not know a lot of 
> things about Prank" block :)
> 
> We do not know that Sirius would have been overjoyed if Snape had 
> died at the hands of Lupin, we just do not know that.
> 
> And Sirius does not say I wish Snape was killed, he just does not.
> 
> We do not know that Sirius' danger feeling after monthly outings 
> with werewolf was the same as it has to be. Yeah, I think he could 
> have just forgotten that for those kids who could not turn in big 
> animals werewolf can be dangerous, more than for him.
> 
> In short, I disagree that Sirius would have been happy if Snape 
> died. I mean he could have been I just do not think we know it.
> 

colebiancardi back again:

true, true.  However, Sirius never held back his hatred for Snape and
vice versa;  I mean, what if Lupin had bit Snape?  Then Snape becomes
a furry problem as well.  

Sirius and Snape never got over their hatred for each other.  Just as
Snape didn't cry buckets of tears over Sirius' demise, I am going to
go out on a limb here and state, in my humble opinion, I doubt Sirius
would have been remorseful over Snape's demise if it had come to that.
 I also believe, and this isn't a stretch by any means, that there is
no love lost between the two of them.  

The "prank" was Sirius's idea alone (although, I wouldn't be surprised
if Peter knew about it before hand) and when James found out about it,
he knew that Sirius had gone too far.

I don't believe that Sirius forgot how dangerous a werewolf could be -
he didn't in PoA.


colebiancardi