Did Snape set up the Pensieve scene?

montavilla47 montavilla47 at yahoo.com
Sun Jun 3 03:44:40 UTC 2007


No: HPFGUIDX 169704

> Nikkalmati
> Also, this brings up something that has been bothering me about the  
> Occlumency/Pensieve situation.   When Harry reports to Sirius and  Lupin that he had 
> stopped the lessons they are outraged.  Sirius threatens  to come and talk to 
> Snape and Lupin insists to Harry that he must take the  lessons and manages to 
> calm Sirius by promising that he will bring it up with  DD.  But NOTHING is 
> done!  Does Lupin ever talk to DD?  (Is  Pippin right?  <g>) 

Montavilla47:
The only thing that I can figure is that there was an emergency meeting between Snape, 
DD, and Lupin (and perhaps Sirius) in which Snape pointed out some compelling reason 
not to continue the classes.  (Before HBP, I would have thought "I don't wanna!" would be 
enough, but after that argument in the forest, I don't think so.)

It may have been simply that Dumbledore realized that Snape and Harry were too 
distrustful of each other to get any good outcome from continued lessons.






More information about the HPforGrownups archive