Snape and Malfoy (Narcissa)

[dungrollin]

No: HPFGUIDX 169816

Sonya:
> I have to admit the secret love child theory is very un-potterish.
> But the loved Narcissa is still staying with me... I lurve the
> unrequited love that Narcissa unabashedly uses to manipulate snape.
> 
> But sadly I feel the need for romance.  Oh yes, she in my head liked
> him back a bit - or was at least drawn to him at tough times... my
> main thing is Narcissa knowing exactly where he lived and Bellatrix
> completely in the dark.  Also his rection on first opening the door
> and calling her by her first name then his quiet smirk when Bellatrix 
walks in. I think Narcissa has been there before...Plus the pressing 
his hands to her lips. That's quite intimate!
> 

Dungrollin:

I was, for a while, quite enamoured of the idea that Snape and Narcissa 
had something going in secret, and then Voldemort gave Narcissa to 
Lucius as a reward for some service (killing Regulus?), and it was 
losing Narcissa which sent Snape to Dumbledore. Perhaps Lucius keeps 
Narcissa topped up with a love potion, and once Lucius was put in 
Azkaban the effects started to wear off, and Narcissa started to 
realise that her life was a lie. 

In this scenario Draco could be Snape's son, and Snape would know that 
if anything happened to Lucius Draco would suffer, which is why we got 
the twitch at the end of GoF when Harry mentioned Lucius being at the 
graveyard. 

But I don't think it'll work out, since DD said it was how Voldemort 
interpreted the prophecy which prompted Snape's betrayal of the Death 
Eaters. There's certainly something about Snape and the Malfoys that 
we don't yet know, and given that we've had the clues from so early on, 
it will probably be important. For what it's worth, here's my post-HBP 
version of what made Snape move back to DD's camp (which does involve 
the Malfoys), and to which I still adhere.

http://groups.yahoo.com/group/HPforGrownups/message/160658

Unfortunately the LOLLIPOPS-stained fingers of HPfGU listies weren't 
forthcoming in providing support or agreement (despite my oodles of 
canon), but hey, it's my theory, it definitely floats and I'm sticking 
with it!

Dungrollin