What Harry "knows", Was Why we'll get no further revelations Snape was Evil

[Dana]

No: HPFGUIDX 169822

colebiancardi:
> Now, regardless if Snape is DDM (which I believe 99.99999%) or ESE
> (the rest of the percentage), we would need the revelation of what 
> the remorseful story was that he told DD & why DD trusted him so 
> much.  I would also like, but it is not necessary, the reason why 
> Snape became a DE.  And how Snape managed to hookwink either DD or 
> LV, depending on the flavor he is.  If Snape is DDM, I would like, 
> although it is not necessary, the reason why he took the UV.
<snip>

Dana:
Maybe it is just me but the reason for DD's trust in Snape will not 
explain Snape's loyalty one bit. Someone else's trust is not a 
security on how a person fullfills that trust. LV trusts Snape too 
and he must have his reasons. James trusted Peter and he still 
betrayed him. DD's trust in Snape was already explained in HBP, Snape 
said he regretted how LV interpretted the prophecy and DD believed 
him.

colebiancardi:
> We don't need more on the Prank (although I would love it).  We 
> don't need more about the UV or Spinner's End if he is ESE.  If he 
> is ESE, that chapter is self-explanatory and really doesn't need 
> anything more.  If Snape is DDM, a few words on the UV, as I stated 
> above, would be nice, but isn't really needed.  
> 
> I really cannot think why we would need more other than that.  He is
> one of the three flavors above and one of those, OFH, needs further 
> no explanation or reasons.
<snip>

Dana:
Well for me it will be fine if JKR never mentions Snape again but I 
mustn't get my hopes up. Snape unfortunately is part of the main 
story about Harry's life and I believe he was put in there to show 
what the other side of love can do to a person and the influences it 
has on the personal choices that person makes because of it. I do not 
believe Snape's motives were because he is ESE or DDM but because he 
is the only important person in his own world. Your OFH is based on 
him wanting to rule the WW but to me it is about Snape wanting to be 
the centre of his own world. To him appriciation probably is love but 
it actually has far less dept then actual love. 

I would love more information about the prank but not because I want 
to understand Snape's motives for going in but I like to know more 
about Sirius's motives for giving him the information about how to 
get passed the willow and James's for saving Snape. I probably will 
never get it but oh well you can't have everything. 

Dana