Petunia's Eyes

[Meridel1 at aol.com]

No: HPFGUIDX 169876

Karen:
Someone please read what I'm thinking most recently and try to find some reason why this couldn't be true. I really think it makes a lot of sence but I want others to check it. Furthermore, do we know who is older- Petunia or Lily?
<snip>
Now what are your thoughts on this? I have gotten responces from others saying that then there would be no blood protection at no. 4 then if Petunia and Lily were not blood related. However, someone else said, "At the end of 'Will and Won't' in HBP, Petunia looks 'oddly flushed' when DD is talking about the blood protection. " Interesting... maybe she knows that there is no blood relation with her and Lily... Thoughts please...



Meredith:

Hi all.

I'm new here and am currently re-reading all 6 books before #7 comes out.  I've just started #6. However, this particular topic is something I've been thinking about for quite awhile now.  I definitely feel that the Durselys are going to figure prominently in #7 - but exactly how, I'm not sure.  However, as far as the Lily/Petunia/Harry relationship goes.... this might be really far-fetched - but has anyone considered the possibility that Lily isn't Harry's biological mother?