Voldemort's original body/Mrs Figg/New Art Revealed
or.phan_ann
orphan_ann at hotmail.co.uk
Fri Jun 8 22:05:10 UTC 2007
No: HPFGUIDX 170028
In message #169956 Carol wrote:
>I have the same problem. If his body was found, mutilated or
>otherwise, he would be firmly believed to be dead. If his body wasn't
>found, how does anyone know for sure that he didn't just run away
>after killing the adult Potters and failing to kill Harry. Is it only
>Dumbledore's (and spy!Snape's) word that Voldemort was after the
>Potters? Why is everyone celebrating?
Ann:
I know that was posted a few days ago, but I've only just been
thinking about this. Firstly, we don't know much about what happened
at Godric's Hollow at all. For all we know there *was* a body. But if
there was, remember, it had just had a house collapse on it. If so, I
doubt a detailed description will be forthcoming. As to why we know
so little about what happened that night, I think that's JKR assuming
we'd fill in the basic blanks and knowing that she had more to add
on the topic. The waiter recommends a side order of Shesezso to
compliment the exquisite taste of this idea!
Onwards and upwards. People have been wondering lately who
might "perform magic late in life", so I thought I'd add my tuppence
worth. This has to be a non-magical character, i.e. a muggle or
squib, which means the candidates are Filch, Mrs Figg, or one of the
three Dursleys. (Unless it's some character who's only been mentioned
once before or something, which I would consider Not Fair.) Of the
five, none of the Dursleys are late in life - IMHO, Petunia and
Vernon are only in their forties. Not much has been made of Filch's
age, and I think he's unlikely anyway, so my money's firmly on Mrs
Figg.
Lastly, seeing the DH special edition cover (which I think is great,
by the by) made me wonder about the theories of regular/symmetrical
repetition in the series. I'm vaguely convinced that DH will have
something to do with PoA. But dragons have cropped up twice in the
novels before: PS/SS (Norbert) and GoF (the First Task.) Does anyone
else think there might be something to this? What happens in books 1
and 4 *only*? The first thing that comes to my mind is that both
climax in a formal maze, the obstacle course in PS/SS and the Third
Task in GoF, and then Voldemort turns up.
Ann, expecting Mrs Figg to turn into a dragon in DH <g>
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive