Dobby and Horcruxes

[Donna]

No: HPFGUIDX 170065

Earlier I stated that the DEs know about the horcruxes and
someone informed me that was against the canon. DD said that
the DEs didn't know about the horcruxes in HBP..Well I say
DD was wrong. Now give me a chance to prove myself..OK

In the HBP, DD states two things that are revelant to my
proof

1. That he didn't know that the diary was a horcrux until
the end of COS

2. That Lucius Malfoy didn't know that he had a horcrux
because. He was so careless with it and wanted to embarrass
Mr Weasley with a dark object

Lets go back to COS. The main theme on this book is "things
aren't always as they seem"

In the bedroom scene with Dobby, Dobby warns Harry of a
"plot" against him specifically, but couldn't tell him who
is plotting against him. We learn later that Dobby is the
house elf of the Malfoy's and he cannot rat on his master.

Harry asked if LV is involved. Dobby thinks then shakes his
head but tries to tell Harry with his eyes that he is "warm".
Harry guesses LV's brother.  No says Dobby. IMO Dobby was
trying to tell Harry about TOM RIDDLE. Therefore, Dobby knows
about the horcrux and the Malfoy's. Dobby warns Harry about
dark magic,that DD DOESN'T KNOW ABOUT!!

Now let's look at Lucius Malfoy's actions on Diagonally Alley
in COS.

First we see him in Bogins and Burkes trying to sell his dark
magic items at his home.  Why not the disry also with these
other dark objects?

Also there seems to be some secret dialogue between Mr. Burke
and Lucius Malfoy..Maybe the diary was in the shop and Lucius
Malfoy was picking it up.

Next we see him in Flourish and Blotts planting the diary in
Ginny Weasley's books. He also PROTECTS THE DIARY during the
scuffle with Mr. Weasley DD was wrong..Lucius Mafoy knew
exactly what he was doing, knew he had a horcrux,and was
protective of it rather than careless.

A horcrux also kills when it becomes "alive" again sucking the
life force from it's victim.  What better victim than an
innocent,protected, lively, first year student for a horcrux.
Ginny Weasley the only girl in a family of all boys  the apple
in everyone's eyes. Her death would be a terrible blow to the
Weasley family. No Lucius knew exactly what he was doing

Donna