[HPforGrownups] Re: Snape - a werewolf bigot?? Was: Say it isn't so Lupin!!!

[Phyllis Stevens]

No: HPFGUIDX 170124

Magpie wrote concerning Snape:
We've never seen him exhibit any particular prejudice 
against Muggle-borns during the story when we've seen 
him--though as I've said before, that in itself doesn't 
seem to be an insurmountable problem with Slughorn.

--

What about the fact that he almost always ignores Hermione 
each time she raises her hand in class. I realize that she 
is one who knows most of the answers through her studying 
prior to class, but to simply ignore her and grudgingly 
calling on her seems to me to be a muggle resentment as 
well as perhaps a prejudice against the group. Wasn't 
Lily also very intelligent? Maybe she reminds him of Lily, 
so again he has a personal reason to not like Hermione, 
therefore, it looks as if he is prejudice against all 
muggle-borns.  So again we are back to is he prejudice
against all werewolves or just the personal dislike of 
Lupin. Still waiting to find out about all this!


catlady1949 at comcast.net

add me to your MSN:

Catlady1949 at Comcast.net